Poor Miss Bennet-with three sisters married, she will no doubt be left "on the shelf" unless she takes steps to secure her own happiness. So, with the arrival of Mr. Yarby, a handsome new rector for Longbourn chapel, Mary decides to use her Biblical knowledge to win his heart.

Meanwhile, her recently widowed father finds himself falling for the older sister of his new reverend. But Mr. Bennet is officially in mourning for his late wife-what a scandalous situation! Unfortunately, Longbourn's heir, Mr. Collins, has the antennae for a scandal and makes blackmail threats.

Will an overheard conversation between the Yarby siblings break Mary's heart? Or will it impel her to a desperate act that threatens everyone's hopes for lasting love?